You are here: Home » Opinion » Letters »

Letter: A different point of view

September 3, 2012 12:48 PM

Share this Article

Tags:

Editor:

Regarding the appointment of Ms. Lael Rubin to the Santa Monica Airport Commission (“New airport commissioner breaks mold,” Sept. 1-2), I find that, possibly for the first time in my life, I agree with Martin Rubin when he says that her appointment was a “missed opportunity.”

I believe, though, that the missed opportunity was the City Council’s failure to appoint someone to the commission who is a pilot or who is connected to aviation in some way. It’s almost beyond belief (except, perhaps, in Santa Monica) that an Airport Commission (of any city) would not have as a member a pilot or someone who is connected in some way to the aeronautical world. But, it’s unfortunately true that Santa Monica’s Airport Commission does not have any member who can provide that “flying” point of view. Santa Monica’s airport commission members are all party faithful appointed by other party faithful.

What is the City Council afraid of? Do they fear having a commission member who does not support the closing of the airport, or who holds a different, broader point of view? This is a rigged game.

The airport has a right to exist and it has a right to be represented on the Airport Commission. Santa Monica has over 96,000 inhabitants. The “airport closers” number only a few hundred and those are concentrated around the airport. A “closer” admitted to me that even in the communities right around the airport, the residents do not all agree with closing the airport. When he walks around his neighborhood trying to drum up support, many people disagree with him and others are supporters of the airport. The “closers” would love for you to believe that their voice is the voice of the people, but it is not, not even in the neighborhoods closest to the airport.

The airport’s local economic impact has been valued by consultants hired by the city (probably to their dismay) at $275.2 million dollars annually. On-SMO businesses number 177 and represent 30 industry groups; this is not just a matter of six flight schools. About 1,500 jobs and the families who depend on those jobs are dependent on the airport. Separate from that economic impact is the airport itself. Except for some money paid for capital improvements, the airport breaks even as an airport — no money from other things like education, police and fire has to be diverted to support the airport.

Santa Monicans need to be aware that the FAA has offered to buy the homes that the city has said are in “harms’ way,” but Santa Monica refused the offer. The FAA has also offered to pay for some additional safety features for the airport, but Santa Monica refused the offer. The “airport closers” don’t want you to know that!

We can only hope that Ms. Lael Rubin talks to some other people with differing views and does not confine her discussions only with the City Council and her other airport commissioners, who seem to have a vested interest in closing the airport. The views of the FAA, the pilots, the airport businesses and their employees and the many, many people here in Santa Monica who view the airport as a real asset need to be heard.

Reynold Dacon

Santa Monica

See this story as it appeared in the paper

Other News

City Hall rethinking water usage

CITYWIDE — Taking a shower, flushing toilets, watering the lawn — daily life requires water, and managing that need in a town of 90,000 residents and upwards of 200,000 workers and visitors is a challenge that City Hall is trying to conquer. City officials saddled themselves with a stringent goal in 2010, the last time that they took on the Urban Water Management Plan required by the state, committing the city to consume only 123 gallons per person, per day [...]
Read more →
Environment Featured News
Mr. Checkpoint goes to court

CITY HALL — A Santa Monica resident known for his website that shares DUI checkpoint locations has found himself on the other side of the coin fighting a civil rights case with City Hall over a 2011 incident in which he was arrested on suspicion of driving drunk. Sennett Devermont, the man behind MrCheckpoint.com, alleged in a lawsuit filed last year that the Santa Monica police officer who pulled him over for an illegal right-hand turn against a red light [...]
Read more →
Crime Featured News
Playoffs: Samohi moves on; New Roads out

SANTA ANA, Calif. — Santa Monica softball used the long ball to dispatch No. 1 seeded Segerstrom from the second round of the CIF-Southern Section Division 4 playoffs on Tuesday. Samohi’s Sara Garcia blasted two home runs in the contest and starting pitcher Whitney Jones overcame two early runs to shut down Segerstrom’s offense. The win sends Samohi to the third round of the playoffs today, Thursday, at home against Paloma Valley. The game begins at 3:15 p.m. Samohi finished [...]
Read more →
Featured High School Sports
Brief: Art for a cause

The seventh annual ART for CLARE event will be held at Bergamot Station on Sunday, June 2, from 1 p.m. to 4 p.m. The charity event will include an art action with works by Ed Ruscha, Kim McCarty and actor Anthony Hopkins; a silent auction with items ranging from luxury vacations to sports memorabilia; live music and food from some of the area’s best eateries, including Lemonade and El Cholo. Bergamot Station is located at 2525 Michigan Ave. Advance tickets [...]
Read more →
Arts Entertainment Life Non Profits
Brief: Civic to have one more show

The Santa Monica Symphony Orchestra will perform a farewell concert for the Santa Monica Civic Auditorium on Saturday, May 25, before the historic venue closes at the end of June. The concert will feature works from renowned composer Pyotr Ilyich Tchaikovsky, such as movements from “The Sleeping Beauty Ballet” and his “Fifth Symphony.” The finale of the “1812 Overture” will end the concert. Santa Monica resident, professor of cello at UCLA and Grammy Award-winner Antonio Lysy will be a featured [...]
Read more →
Entertainment Featured Life
Premiere with Placido a rare treat

It’s not everyday that an opera conducted by a superstar premieres in your backyard, but that’s what took place at the Broad Stage in Santa Monica last Friday. LA Opera Off Grand is a new series that will bring opera to venues beyond LA Opera’s Music Center homebase. “Dulce Rosa,” based on a short story by Isabel Allende, marks the series debut and the first time The Broad has hosted a fully-staged opera. LA Opera General Director Placido Domingo conducts [...]
Read more →
Culture Watch Featured Life
If your name is ‘mud’ can ‘grunge’ be far behind?

Matthew McConaughey is the personification of mud, physically and emotionally. “Mud” is the story of a lovelorn loser and the teenage boys who help him evade the avenging family of a man he’s killed. It’s also a love story in which everyone loses. And a bittersweet coming-of-age story — for Mud (McConaughey) as well as for the boys. While the plot and the surroundings would lead one to assume that the film is going to be an emotional downer, it [...]
Read more →
Featured Life Play Time
New source of natural gas

The name “natural gas” might be a puzzle. After all, how could there be such a thing as unnatural gas? The reason we call natural gas what we do has to do with history. There was a day that people made burnable gas by heating coal. The gases that came off the coal were piped around cities where they did things like light street lamps and even power cook stoves in homes. Coal gas had its downside. For one thing, [...]
Read more →
Columns Opinion Your Column Here
Letter: Who’s it for?

Editor: Will the light rail really serve the residents of Santa Monica? The more I read about the Expo Metro rail, the more I get an impression that it is built only to bring more people to Santa Monica and not to serve the residents of the city. There is no mention of the parking arrangements if you want to use the Metro rail. After all, very few people live within walking distance from the rail stations. At least in [...]
Read more →
Letters Opinion
Letter: No civility

Editor: Last Thursday evening I was looking forward to hearing more about the environmental impact report concerning the Miramar Hotel’s proposed development from City Hall’s Planning Director David Martin and his staff. When I got to the library, it was clear that a professionally organized opposition group was hell bent on sabotaging the meeting. Flyers were being handed out which were nothing more than scurrilous attacks on the owner of the hotel, computer innovator Michael Dell. After a short presentation [...]
Read more →
Letters Opinion
City Hall calls for cuts, increased fees to balance budget

CITY HALL — Life in Santa Monica could get more expensive for residents, visitors and businesses as City Hall works to close a potential $13.2 million budget gap that looms within the next four years without cutting services residents have come to expect. The City Council will get its first crack at proposals next week, which include new programs that officials hope will net $1.1 million as well as increased fees that could bring in $1.45 million in new revenue. [...]
Read more →
Featured Government News
UC hospitals say patients safe despite strike

LOS ANGELES — Thousands of workers at University of California medical centers began a two-day strike on Tuesday that prompted the postponement of dozens of surgeries amid reassurances that patients were safe. A union representing some 13,000 hospital pharmacists, nursing assistants, operating room scrubs and other health care workers began the walkout at 4 a.m. at medical facilities in San Diego, Orange, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, San Francisco and Sacramento. Nurses were not on strike, emergency rooms were open, and about 450 [...]
Read more →
Featured News
Softball: Rout ends Pacifica Christian’s surprising season

CLOVER PARK — Pacifica Christian was just bounced from the playoffs 12-0 at the hands of Academy for Academic Excellence, but there wasn’t a long face to be found. Instead of pouting over the loss in the second round of the CIF-Southern Section Division 7 softball playoffs on Tuesday at Clover Park, the Seawolves came together for one last cheer before packing it up for the off-season. The first-year team exceeded everybody’s expectations, including those of head coach Mike Dolan. [...]
Read more →
Featured High School Sports
Rockers help raise $125K for arts

Rock ‘n’ Roll Hall of Fame inductee Jackson Browne headlined the 10th annual Artists for the Arts benefit concerts this past weekend at Santa Monica High School’s Barnum Hall, helping to raise $125,000 for arts programs. Browne shared the stage with fellow rock icon Gary Wright, known for “Dreamweaver” and other classic rock hits, and local rock band Venice, a touring group with more than 20 years playing with some of the biggest names in music, officials with the Santa [...]
Read more →
Education Featured News Public
Experiencing death too soon

“I saw a man die,” Amina says as she explains why she’s not smiling in her passport photo. We are sitting in the teenager’s modest living room — which doubles as a bedroom and dining room — in Damascus, to where she and her family fled after the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq. I have joined Abdullah, whom I met in Baghdad in 2003 just before the war, and his teenage daughters at their spotless, spare two-bedroom flat that they share [...]
Read more →
Columns Opinion
Legislature’s assault on Prop. 13 begins

Last week we alerted California taxpayers as to the immediate threats to Proposition 13 being heard by a California legislative committee. As fully anticipated, the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance approved all six of the anti-Prop. 13 proposals. All of the bills in question would gut one of the most important provisions of Proposition 13 — the two-thirds vote requirement for additional “add on” parcel taxes. These “add on” parcel and bond taxes are on top of the property [...]
Read more →
Columns Opinion The Tax Man