Five people have taken or attempted to take their own lives in parking structures in Downtown Santa Monica since last September, and experts say it might be time for City Hall to consider ways to prevent future attempts.

Mark Kaplan, a professor at UCLA’s Luskin School of Public Affairs who studies suicide, said five suicides or suicide attempts at similar locations in a yearlong period is cause for concern.

“I wouldn’t call it an epidemic, but I’d call it an issue,” he said.

Four individuals died between September 2018 and August of this year. Last Sunday, Santa Monica Police Department officers talked down an individual who planned to jump from the roof of Parking Structure 3.

SMPD responded to 30 other calls for suicides or attempted suicides between September 2018 and September 2019, according to public records. Every officer receives training on suicides, mental health and crisis negotiation, and the department maintains a crisis negotiation team that responds to calls for suicide, said Lt. Candice Cobarrubias.

City manager Rick Cole said last Sunday’s suicide attempt suggests a pattern may be taking hold, but he noted that suicide routinely occurs in less visible locations in Santa Monica, including at the beach and in homes and garages.

Cole said he plans to discuss possible measures to prevent suicide in downtown parking structures with local stakeholders.

“I am committed to convening thoughtful discussions with medical experts, law enforcement, Downtown Santa Monica stakeholders and city officials to assess whether there are additional steps we can take to divert troubled individuals from making a fatal mistake,” he said.

A 2016 survey of members of the International Parking & Mobility Institute, the world’s largest association of professionals in parking, transportation and mobility, found that 48% had experienced a suicide or suicide attempt in one of their parking structures.

A 2016 IPMI report on suicide in parking structures published the same year lists physical barriers, cameras and signage as possible prevention measures. But barriers come at a high cost, the report said.

“The University of Iowa is performing a study to screen seven campus garages, with an estimated total construction cost of $1.5 million,” the report said. “The cost to screen levels four and higher in a seven- or eight-level garage is about $220,000, based on this study.”

Local experts agreed that fences or barriers discourage individuals from jumping.

“It’s often an impulsive act, and there’s research showing that people think twice if there’s a barrier,” Kaplan said. “That doesn’t mean people won’t go elsewhere or take their own lives some other way, but you can at least erect barriers that reduce the possibility of this happening again.”

All but one of the 10 public parking structures in Downtown Santa Monica have steel cables or grid fencing enclosing their top levels, but the barriers are no taller than 6 feet.

Studies have shown taller barriers to be effective deterrents, said Lyn Morris, senior vice president of clinical operations at Didi Hirsch Mental Health Services, a Los Angeles-based organization that provides free mental health, substance abuse disorder and suicide prevention services.

“If it’s something the average-sized person could crawl and get over with a little effort, it wouldn’t serve as the barrier you need,” she said.

Morris said putting up signs with suicide hotline information and training parking employees to identify people who seem at risk of suicide could also help prevent suicide attempts.

Suicides in Los Angeles Metro train stations dropped when Didi Hirsch put up signs in 2013, she said. The organization also trained all Metro operators to recognize behaviors that could indicate someone is contemplating suicide.

“It’s important to have signs in places leading up to where they may jump, which in parking structures would be the elevators and stairwells,” she said. “Anything that can interrupt their thought process at that point is helpful, and suicide hotline signage lets people know there’s a confidential, anonymous resource out there.”

Morris also recommended training community members to identify signs of suicide.

“If you see somebody looking distraught walking alone at night in a parking structure, it wouldn’t hurt to say, “you look lost, can I help you with something?”,” she said. “Again, it interrupts their thought process. Often, people think they shouldn’t intervene, but just asking someone if they’re okay can make a huge difference.”

If you or someone you know may be struggling with suicidal thoughts, you can call the U.S. National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 800-273-TALK (8255) any time day or night, or chat online.

Crisis Text Line also provides free, 24/7, confidential support via text message to people in crisis when they dial 741741.

madeleine@smdp.com

Join the Conversation

2 Comments

  1. article decribed poor inadequate responses from apparently local =’experts in SM for parking lot suicides – putting up sign? that a depressed, drugged, unhappy person is going to read ? huh? that is so meager, cheap, pretending to be “of help” means that such ” administrators ” are ineffective to ‘help’ those intending on exiting their miserable lives but effective at getting $$$ funding for such non-useful PR promoting responses .

    and saying : “Morris also recommended training community members to identify signs of suicide….
    “If you see somebody looking distraught walking alone at night in a parking structure, it wouldn’t hurt to say, “you look lost, can I help you with something?”,” she said. ” as noted above, please have any woman, or middle-class man who is not prepared to offer his wallet or all in it or get yelled at with intense, intimidating anger, had better not try that fake-method…of contact.

    offer some people – even in Sm – a mealy dollar [$1 ]and be yelled at or refused… or be taken a fool and asked for more with a lie-excuse of what need there could be. – done it ? we have. and learned how badly many homeless, drugged, depressed, [suicidal too ] people want MORE than a little bit or a sweet-smile either. Even the usual alcoholic routine of “god bless you” in tone is different than words imply…..
    resentment for giver having more and not offering them more… while trying to take away an image of “i am so good … i helped them !” – not so.

    so help for strangers frequenting parking lots takes a lot more courage, deeper concern and not to get in newspaper, even this one, for their own promotional-PR benefits….

    help more directly and not just with cash or a ‘free lunch bag’ or sweet friendly presentations – PLEAE EVALUATE HOW DIRE AND SERIOUS THESE PEOPLE’S LIVES AND CONDITIONS ACTUALLY and factually are.

    dont give the rest of readers glib simple ineffective words to just look as if… help were just that …

    this exposed interview just made more visible how unhelpful so many funded agencies can be – or at least present themselves poorly – even if that was not the quoted administrator’s intent, indeed !
    sad.

  2. Thank you for bringing attention to this issue and a well researched article. The approaches given by the experts you sited are factual and do help. I hope DTSM will implement them soon. We all can help our community.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published.