The Board of Education will consider selecting a seventh member to fill the seat left vacant by State Senator Ben Allen (D-Santa Monica) at its meeting this Thursday.
Ten of the 11 candidates who submitted applications were deemed eligible by the Santa Monica-Malibu Unified School District — former Santa Monica High School baseball coach Kurt Schwengel would have to quit his teaching job to take the seat — and they will each be given 15 minutes to speak to the board in public.
The term on Allen’s vacant seat expires at the end of 2016.
At least four of the remaining six board members will have to agree on a candidate to fill that seat.
Three of the 10 applicants were losers in November’s election. This includes Ralph Mechur, who served on the board since 2007 and is considered one of the favorites to fill the seat.
Mechur was appointed the first time around and won his first election in 2010. He finished fifth in a race for four seats in November and is seeking another appointment.
Jon Kean, who’s currently the PTA President at Lincoln Middle School and previously served as the PTA President at Roosevelt Elementary, is on that list, as is Tom Larmore, an attorney and former partnerat Harding Larmore Kutcher & Kozal. In his application Larmore notes that he’s seeking appointment for a number of reasons, including the fact that he supports public education but sees the district losing students to private schools.
Jake Wachtel, who placed eighth out of eight candidates in the 2010 Ed Board race, pulling in just over 6,000 votes, is eligible for the seat. He has served as a PTA President at Grant Elementary and worked previously as a coach and a teacher.
Jennifer deNicola has been one of the most vocal advocates for the removal of PCBs from schools. DeNicola, a Malibu resident, speaks at many of the Ed Board meetings, calling for greater transparency surrounding the environmental and health concerns at Malibu High School.
Larry Droeger, of the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office, is applying for the open seat because he has two kids currently in the district and one who just graduated from Malibu High School.
David Hays, a Malibu resident, is the parent of two teenage students formerly in the district.
Sion Roy, a member of the Santa Monica Democratic Club’s executive committee, is eligible. He’s a cardiologist at Harbor UCLA and chairs the district’s Health and Safety advisory committee.
Dhun May, who placed seventh out of eight in November’s election, filed for the seat. She received 5,169 votes.
Patty Finer, who placed eighth in November’s election, submitted an application. She pulled in 5,148 votes.
Each candidate will be asked the same four questions and there will be no follow-up questions. This is, according to the district, to ensure impartiality.
They will have two minutes for an opening statement, two minutes for each of the four questions, and time for a “brief closing statement.”
Board members will have five minutes between each candidate to record their own notes.
After the interview process, the public will have a chance to speak and the board will have a chance to deliberate in open session.
Then board members will nominate candidates. Each board member will write his or her choice down on a piece of paper and a district official will read the votes aloud.
“If one of the nominees has received four or more votes, then the board will make a motion, second, and cast a verbal vote to appoint the applicant to fill the vacancy on the board,” district officials said in a report. “If none of the nominees receive four or more votes, the board members will begin the deliberation, nomination, and voting process over until one of the candidates has received four or more votes.”
If no one challenges the appointment through a petition within 30 days, the decision will be considered final.
If the decision were successfully challenged, it would go to a special election, which could cost the district hundreds of thousands or dollars.
The meeting will take place at the district’s administrative offices, at 1651 16th Street in Santa Monica. The public meeting is scheduled to begin at 5:30 p.m. on Thursday.
dave@www.smdp.com
They’re writing their nominations on pieces of paper–submitting them anonymously? What ever happened to the transparency and accountability that three of the present board members promised after past PR debacles (including the special ed gag orders)? The public has a right to know which board member is nominating which candidate. Are secret ballots in a public meeting even legal, according to the Brown Act?
The SMMUSD is Spending an Outrageous Amount of Money to Distract the Parents and Students and desperately needs new leadership.
The PCB levels have come back at some of the highest in the nation and the EPA has ordered the removal of PCBs including those from independent tests. So the 3.7 million dollar question is, why spend over 3.7 million dollars with Environ doing “distraction” testing and Pillsbury Law firm rather than spend it to remove PCBs from our children’s schools?
Especially when the costs to remove PCB-laced caulking is estimated to be approximately $500,000.
Dec 22, 2014: SMMUSD Releases their Legal and Environmental Expenditures Pursuant to a Public Records Request.
Click to Review invoices from: Environ, Pillsbury Law Firm and Mark Katchen.
http://malibuunites.com/wp-content/uploads/2015/01/PO-Approved-By-Board-pdf.pdf
http://malibuunites.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Santa-Monica-Malibu-USD-Document-Production-Part-1-of-3.pdf
http://malibuunites.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Santa-Monica-Malibu-USD-Document-Production-Part-2-of-3.pdf
http://malibuunites.com/wp-content/uploads/2014/12/Santa-Monica-Malibu-USD-Document-Production-Part-3-of-3.pdf
For a list of many other controversies at the SMMUSD, please visit:
http://smmusdirresponsibilityendangersourchildren.wordpress.com/
New School Board Member
Whatever the SMMUSD Board of Education does, I hope they do not re-appoint Ralph Mechur to the Board. He served during the whole non-disclosure agreement debacle regarding the District’s overuse of settlement agreements with gag orders in special education legal disputes. That whole charade caused the City Council to withhold over $500K from SMMUSD. Not one of the 27 recommendations made for the improvement of special education under Mechur’s tenure has been implemented. Anytime anyone brings up any complaints to him about special ed, he claims that all of the problems are in the past. Try telling that to the parents that come to me currently for guidance in trying to navigate that department for their special needs children. The District only received 117 surveys back regarding special education services. There are over 1300 students that receive special education services. That poor response is a sign of parents that are fed up and think that no one cares about their concerns.
As the former Chair of the Special Education District Advisory Committee, I am fully aware of the concerns of the parents that have gone poorly addressed for the last almost two decades. It’s time for some new leadership that cares about all children, including the ones with disabilities. There’s also the shortchange that keeps happening to the black students, but there’s not enough bandwidth for that complaint. #StudentsWithDisabilitiesMatter #BlackLivesMatter